Internal

Open Source Document

Epistemic Foundation

History at Enlightium begins with God and His will to create, sustain, and govern all things for His glory as revealed in His Word, Scripture. God has spoken plainly about the beginning of human history and its ultimate goal: history’s creation, its fall, the dividing of the peoples, and its redemptive end, where God brings creation to its freedom from sin and death, in the New Heavens and the New Earth. The past and future, therefore, have an Author and a purpose. In this way, history is not an empty class that a historian arranges by his own creativity and design. History has an interpretive framework, namely Scripture; and the historian’s faithfulness is measured by his or her commitment to this framework. By honoring Scripture as the foundation of truth about history, historians produce valid records of the past and helpful guides that shape our understanding of current events.

On this basis, students who study history are creatures inside history, not interpreters above it or creators of it. Students bear God's image. God knows them and their place within His grand narrative and plan. Thus, students naturally learn that the faithful historian is one who, like themselves, begins research in the fear of the Lord, submitted to the Word of the Lord. To study history therefore begins with a scriptural methodology. It is to receive and read history from the account of God’s Word, thoughtfully discerning the actions and relations of persons and nations within that account.

Assumptions Refused

Based on the epistemic anchor, History at Enlightium rejects four unbiblical assumptions carried over from secular social studies education. The corresponding chapter in the state framework reflects all four assumptions. Each assumption, therefore, is rejected and replaced with an alternative grounded in the epistemic anchor above.

First, Enlightium rejects the assumption that historical events can be adequately explained without reference to divine providence, human moral responsibility, and Scripture as the framework for historical interpretation. The state chapter identifies geographic influences on population patterns, economic influences on technology use, and the influence of earlier events on later ones. However, it does not place these influences within Scripture’s account of God’s governance of history, and only two of its twenty-two knowledge and skills statements explicitly address human choice. Enlightium’s history curriculum recognizes the importance of geographic, economic, and other historical factors but rejects the assumption that these factors alone provide an adequate framework for interpreting history. Secular historical explanations depend on philosophical assumptions that may skew history and, therefore, must be evaluated according to God’s Word. As established in the epistemic anchor, historical evidence is situated within the biblical understanding of God’s providence, His covenant dealings with humanity, and human nature.

Second, Enlightium rejects the assumption that religion is merely a product of society. A people’s worship expresses its foundational beliefs, commitments, and understanding of ultimate authority. These commitments shape its laws, institutions, and art. Enlightium’s history curriculum examines how religious beliefs and practices influence culture, while recognizing that culture also influences how those beliefs are expressed.

Third, Enlightium rejects the assumption that historical accounts can be written without an interpretive perspective. The state chapter identifies a person’s frame of reference as an influence on their point of view but does not identify the perspective guiding its own account. Enlightium states its position openly and directly: Scripture is God’s Word and the standard for evaluating the faithfulness of human accounts of history. Students should learn to identify a historian’s assumptions, historical context, and purpose, and consider how these influence the account.

Fourth, Enlightium rejects the assumption that the primary purpose of studying history is to develop patriotism and prepare students to participate in the economy. The state chapter mentions ethics once, in connection with the functioning of an economic system. Enlightium’s history curriculum seeks to glorify God and equip students to love God and serve their neighbors. Students should learn to love their country and honor those in public office while recognizing that their highest loyalty belongs to God. Courses should teach students to evaluate governments and economic systems according to moral standards grounded in God’s character as revealed in His Word. These standards apply regardless of whether a government or economic system functions effectively.

Values Formed (WISE)

Historical accounts describe real people and events. Students therefore have a responsibility to represent the past accurately and fairly. Careless reporting, misleading omissions, and unsupported claims can misrepresent people, including those who are no longer living. Sixth-grade history instruction should develop truthfulness through careful use of evidence and fair treatment of the people being studied, even discovering how historians can bear false witness about people and historical events.

Students should first establish what happened and what evidence supports the account before drawing conclusions or making personal applications. They should distinguish documented facts from a historian’s interpretations and identify the evidence supporting those interpretations. When describing another people’s religious beliefs, students should use accurate terms that adherents would recognize before evaluating those beliefs according to Scripture. Assessment rubrics should evaluate accuracy, use of evidence, reasoning, and fair representation. They should assess students’ understanding of the biblical framework without attempting to measure personal faith. Students should not receive or lose credit merely for agreeing or disagreeing with an expected judgment about a nation, ruler, or religion.

The Lodestar Standards
Lodestar 1 · Sources, Evidence, and the Recovery of What Happened

Lodestar Statement

Students establish what happened from evidence and can say how they know it. They locate and use valid primary and secondary sources, including oral, print, and visual material and artifacts. They tell a primary source from a secondary one. They evaluate any source for validity, credibility, bias, and accuracy. They analyze what a source contains by sequencing, categorizing, comparing, contrasting, identifying cause and effect, finding the main idea, summarizing, generalizing, predicting, and drawing inferences and conclusions. They distinguish a cause from a circumstance that only accompanied an event, and they say where the evidence stops. They organize and interpret information from outlines, reports, databases, and visual material, including graphs, charts, timelines, and maps. They identify the differing points of view held about an event and account for the frame of reference behind each. They state a claim of their own about the past and support it with evidence and reasoning.

Elements

  • L1.1 Locate a primary or secondary source that bears on a question, and say which of the two it is.
  • L1.2 Evaluate a source for validity, credibility, bias, and accuracy, and point to what in the source shows each.
  • L1.3 Sequence events and categorize what a source contains, and place the events on a timeline as a claim about their order.
  • L1.4 Identify a cause and its effect, and distinguish a cause from a circumstance that only accompanied the event.
  • L1.5 Compare and contrast two accounts, find the main idea of each, and summarize either one without distorting it.
  • L1.6 Draw an inference, a generalization, or a prediction from evidence, and say where the evidence stops.
  • L1.7 Organize information from outlines, reports, databases, and visual material, and interpret what a graph, chart, timeline, or map actually shows.
  • L1.8 Identify the differing points of view held about an event, account for the frame of reference behind each, and state a supported claim of one's own.

Epistemic Anchor

This lodestar teaches a student that the past comes to him through witnesses. Someone left a record, and someone else retold it, sometimes centuries later. A letter written by a participant and a summary written three thousand years afterward are different kinds of evidence. A sixth grader who can say why has the habit on which the rest of this course depends. Testing a source is honesty about where a witness stood. Scripture treats testimony the same way. It requires more than one witness, and it warns that the first account of a dispute seems right until someone examines it.

This lodestar applies frame of reference to every human account, including the textbook in front of the student and the paragraph he is about to write. Naming a standpoint does not excuse him from judgment. He must finish by stating a claim of his own and supporting it. Luke's preface to his Gospel is the model. Many accounts existed. Luke investigated carefully, and he wrote so that his reader might know the truth with certainty.

At this grade the work stays modest. A sixth grader is not judging scholarly debates. He learns that accounts have authors and that some authors stood closer to the event than others. He learns that a claim needs support. He learns that a timeline is itself a claim about order.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A source-based claim. The student receives a small set of primary and secondary sources on one question not discussed in class. He states what happened and supports the claim from the sources. He ranks the sources by how much each can bear and explains the ranking. He names one point where the evidence fell short of what he wanted it to prove. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Short exercises that sort primary sources from secondary ones. Single-source evaluations for credibility and bias. Cause-and-effect statements tested against a second source that complicates them. Timelines built from unordered evidence.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Weighing sourcesDistinguishes primary from secondary sources, weighs them against one another, and states what makes each reliable or unreliable for this question.Distinguishes primary from secondary sources and identifies evident bias or unreliability.Uses sources of uneven quality without noting the difference.Treats every source as equal, or dismisses a source without stating grounds.
Evidence and inferenceSupports each claim with evidence that bears directly on it, and marks the point where the evidence runs out.Supports claims with relevant evidence and distinguishes an inference from what a source states.Cites evidence unevenly, or presents an inference as if a source had stated it.Asserts claims without evidence, or lists evidence without using it.
Causal reasoningDistinguishes a cause from an accompanying circumstance and states what in the evidence shows the difference.Identifies causes and effects accurately and in the right order.Names causes and effects but treats sequence alone as proof of cause.Presents unrelated events as a chain, or does not account for why anything happened.
Points of view and standpointAccounts for the frame of reference behind each account, including his own, and still reaches a supported claim.Identifies differing points of view and accounts for the frame of reference behind at least one.Reports differing views without accounting for any, or accounts for them and then declines to judge.Treats one human account as simply true, or concludes that disagreement makes the question unanswerable.
Lodestar 2 · Providence, Human Agency, and the Course of Events

Lodestar Statement

Students explain how societies came to be as they are by tracing a line from what happened earlier to what holds later. They trace a characteristic of a society to the historical events or factors that produced it. They analyze how a past conflict bears on a later condition, and they distinguish a consequence from a coincidence. They identify individuals and groups whose actions changed their societies. They describe the social, political, economic, and cultural contributions of those individuals and groups. They identify scientific discoveries and technological innovations and the people who made them. They explain how resources, economic conditions, and political decisions determine whether a technology is adopted, neglected, or forbidden. They predict the effects of a future discovery or innovation and state the grounds of the prediction. They distinguish what an account attributes to a person's choice from what it attributes to conditions he did not choose.

Elements

  • L2.1 Trace a characteristic of a society to the historical events or factors that produced it, such as colonization, immigration, or trade.
  • L2.2 Analyze how a past conflict bears on a later condition, and distinguish a consequence from a coincidence.
  • L2.3 Identify an individual or group whose actions changed a society, and describe what changed.
  • L2.4 Describe the social, political, economic, and cultural contributions of individuals and groups from societies past and present.
  • L2.5 Identify a scientific discovery or technological innovation and the person or people who made it.
  • L2.6 Explain how resources, economic conditions, and political decisions determine whether a technology is adopted, neglected, or forbidden.
  • L2.7 Predict the social, political, economic, cultural, or environmental effects of a future discovery or innovation, and state the grounds of the prediction.
  • L2.8 Distinguish what an account attributes to a person's choice from what it attributes to conditions he did not choose.

Epistemic Anchor

This lodestar teaches second causes. It forms the capacity to hold two truths together. A man chose, and his choice fell within a history he did not arrange. Nebuchadnezzar besieged Jerusalem because he intended to. Cyrus released the exiles because he decided to. Each acted freely, and each served God's purpose as an instrument. Sixth graders can grasp this. A student who holds both truths can say what a person chose and answered for, and what that person did not arrange.

Lists of names and inventions can be memorized without thought. Two elements turn such a list into an explanation. The student must say why a technology was adopted in one place and neglected in another. He must also say whether an account credits a person or that person's circumstances. Skill and invention are gifts God gives for building. That is the ordinary dignity of a craftsman.

This lodestar keeps prediction and requires its grounds. A forecast with its grounds stated is a reasoned claim, and it can be assessed. A forecast without grounds is a guess. A student who must state what his prediction rests on also learns how little anyone knows of tomorrow.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A causal account. The student takes one condition in a society under study. He traces it back through the events and decisions that produced it. Throughout, he distinguishes what he attributes to a person's choice from what he attributes to circumstances that person did not choose. He closes with one prediction about a consequence not yet worked out, and he states its grounds. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Short cause-and-consequence chains built from a single source. Sorting exercises on brief passages that ask who chose and who was carried along. Cases of a technology adopted in one society and neglected in another. Predictions paired with the grounds they rest on.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Causal reasoningTraces a line from an event to a later condition, distinguishes cause from coincidence, and names what would count against the account.Traces a line from earlier events to a later condition and supports it with evidence.Asserts a connection that rests on sequence alone.Lists events without connecting them, or connects them without evidence.
Human agencyStates what a person chose and answered for, states what he did not arrange, and keeps both in view throughout.Distinguishes what an account credits to choice from what it credits to circumstance.Attends to choice or to circumstance and neglects the other.Treats history as forces with no one acting, or as actors with nothing constraining them.
Contribution and evidenceShows from evidence what an individual or group actually changed and that the change followed from the action.Describes a contribution accurately and identifies its effect.Names a figure and asserts an influence without showing it.Reports a name and a date with no account of what changed.
Prediction and groundsStates a prediction, states its grounds, and says what result would show it wrong.States a prediction and the grounds it rests on.Offers a prediction with grounds that do not support it.Offers a prediction with no grounds, or does not reason about consequences at all.
Lodestar 3 · Land, Place, and the Settling of Peoples

Lodestar Statement

Students explain where peoples settled and why, and how land and people have acted on each other. They explain the geographic factors responsible for patterns of population and for the location of economic activity. They explain how the movement of a people shapes the character of the place it leaves and the place it enters. They locate major physical and human features and the major countries of each world region. They identify the geographic factors that bear on a society's political relationships, including location, physical features, corridors and barriers, and the distribution of natural resources. They describe how people have been affected by physical processes such as earthquakes, floods, and climate. They analyze how people have adapted to their physical environment and how they have modified it. They use maps, globes, coordinates, graphs, and charts to pose and answer questions of location, significance, distribution, and pattern, and to compare regions. They produce accurate maps and charts of their own.

Elements

  • L3.1 Explain the geographic factors responsible for a pattern of population in a place or region.
  • L3.2 Explain how the movement of a people shapes the character of the place it leaves and the place it enters.
  • L3.3 Locate major landforms, bodies of water, and urban centers, and locate the major countries of each world region.
  • L3.4 Explain the geographic factors responsible for the location of an economic activity.
  • L3.5 Identify the geographic factors that bear on a society's political relationships, including location, physical features, corridors and barriers, and the distribution of natural resources.
  • L3.6 Describe how a people has been affected by a physical process such as an earthquake, a flood, or climate.
  • L3.7 Analyze how a people has adapted to its physical environment and how it has modified that environment through work such as mining, irrigation, or building.
  • L3.8 Pose and answer a geographic question of location, significance, distribution, or pattern using maps, globes, coordinates, graphs, and charts, compare regions from such data, and produce a map or chart that presents a pattern accurately.

Epistemic Anchor

Land is given, not chosen. A people does not select its rivers, its mountain passes, or its neighbors. God made the earth, filled it, and gave it to man to work and keep. Geography is therefore part of the account of a people, not the background to it. Where a people was placed shaped what it could grow, whom it had to meet, and what it had to defend. Scripture states this directly. God appointed the times and boundaries of every people, and the earth and everything in it belong to him.

This lodestar runs the explanation in both directions. The environment acts on people, and people act on the environment. The second direction is the work God gave in the dominion mandate. Irrigation works, mines, terraces, and roads carry out a commission, and a commission can be carried out faithfully or ruinously. A student first describes the work accurately and then weighs it. He weighs the good the work served against the claim the land has on those set over it. Weighing competing goods under uncertainty is the work of prudence, and this content is where a sixth grader first practices it.

The tools of geography belong here for a further reason. A map is a claim. A student who can build a map can also be misled by one. Producing a map that presents a pattern honestly is the same discipline as quoting a source honestly.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A regional analysis. The student takes one region or society. He accounts for its pattern of settlement, the location of its main economic activity, and one of its political relationships in terms of geographic factors. He supports the account with a map or chart he has produced. He closes by naming one significant thing about the society that geography does not explain. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Coordinate and location work. Questions of pattern posed and answered from thematic maps. Short cases of adaptation and modification. Paired comparisons of two regions drawn from one data set.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Geographic explanationExplains a pattern of settlement or activity from specific geographic factors, and shows why another explanation fits less well.Explains a pattern accurately from relevant geographic factors.Names geographic features without connecting them to the pattern.Describes a place without explaining anything about it.
Human and environmental reasoningAccounts for both directions: what the environment made possible, and what the people did to it and why.Describes adaptation and modification accurately and connects each to the environment.Attends to one direction and neglects the other.Treats a people as determined by its land, or treats the land as irrelevant to what the people did.
Location and toolsProduces or reads a map, chart, or set of coordinates accurately, and states what the pattern shown actually supports.Locates features and countries accurately and interprets a map, graph, or chart correctly.Locates features with errors, or reads a visual without interpreting it.Cannot locate the features in question, or misreads what a visual presents.
Limits of the explanationNames what geography does not explain about the society, and states what kind of explanation the rest requires.States at least one thing geography does not account for.Refers to limits without naming one.Treats geography as the whole explanation of a people's history.
Lodestar 4 · Work, Provision, and Exchange

Lodestar Statement

Students explain how peoples provide for themselves and trade with one another. They describe how natural resources, labor, capital, and enterprise bear on an economy. They identify the problems that follow when one of these is scarce. They explain how the uneven distribution of resources produces trade and economic interdependence. They compare how societies organize the production and distribution of goods and services. They compare free enterprise, socialist, and communist economies, including the benefits of the United States free enterprise system. They explain why honest dealing is necessary to an economy and not merely useful to it, and they trace what its absence costs. They define and give examples of agricultural, retail, manufacturing, and service industries. They describe what indicators such as life expectancy, gross domestic product, gross domestic product per capita, and literacy measure about a society, and what those indicators leave out.

Elements

  • L4.1 Describe how natural resources, labor, capital, and enterprise bear on the economy of a society.
  • L4.2 Identify the problems that arise when one of the factors of production is in short supply.
  • L4.3 Explain how the uneven distribution of resources produces trade and economic interdependence, both among societies and within them.
  • L4.4 Compare how two societies organize the production and distribution of goods and services.
  • L4.5 Compare free enterprise, socialist, and communist economies, including the benefits of the United States free enterprise system.
  • L4.6 Explain why honest dealing is necessary to an economy, and give an instance of an economy harmed by its absence.
  • L4.7 Define and give examples of agricultural, retail, manufacturing, and service industries.
  • L4.8 Describe what indicators such as life expectancy, gross domestic product, gross domestic product per capita, and literacy measure, and name something about a society's condition that they do not measure.

Epistemic Anchor

Work came before the fall, and scarcity came after it. That order makes this content clear to a sixth grader. God placed Adam in the garden to work it and keep it while everything was still good. Labor is not the punishment. The thorns and the sweat are the punishment. Three things follow. There is real work to be done. There is not enough of everything. Exchange is one way a person serves a neighbor he will never meet.

This lodestar grounds the economy in the command, not the command in the economy. God commands honest weights and measures. An economy holds together because people obey that command. The student still traces what dishonest dealing costs. The cost is real, and tracing it shows him that the command is not arbitrary. Scripture condemns a merchant with two sets of weights before it counts what he did to the market.

Indicators such as gross domestic product per capita are easily taught as a ranking of peoples. This lodestar requires the student to say what an indicator does not measure. A society can be rich and wretched. Another can be poor and full of faithfulness. A student who can name what an indicator leaves out has learned its honest use. He has not been taught to distrust arithmetic.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A comparative economic account of two societies. The student explains how each society organizes production and distribution, what its resources and factors of production allow, and what it trades and why. He closes by assessing what the common indicators show and conceal about the condition of each society. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Identifying the factors of production in concrete cases. Short scarcity scenarios. Classifying industries. Brief exercises that read one indicator and state its limits. Cases of dishonest dealing traced to their economic consequences.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Economic reasoningExplains how the factors of production, scarcity, and distribution together shape a particular economy, using a concrete case.Applies the factors of production and the effects of scarcity accurately to a society under study.Recites the factors correctly but cannot apply them to a case.Confuses the factors, or treats an economy as having no structure to explain.
Comparison of systemsCompares the systems by how each answers the same questions of production and distribution, and states the benefits and costs of each accurately.Compares free enterprise, socialist, and communist economies accurately, including the benefits of the United States system.Compares the systems by label and not by how each works.Misstates what a system is, or reduces the comparison to approval and disapproval.
Commercial honestyStates why honest dealing is required, and traces from a case what its absence cost an economy.States the ground of honest dealing and identifies a consequence of its absence.Asserts that honesty matters without a ground or a consequence.Treats honest dealing as optional, or as valuable only because cheating is punished.
Use of indicatorsReads an indicator correctly, states what it measures, and names what it cannot show about the life of a people.Uses indicators accurately and notes at least one limit.Uses indicators to rank societies without qualification.Misreads the indicators, or dismisses measurement as meaningless.
Lodestar 5 · Authority, Citizenship, and the Limits of Power

Lodestar Statement

Students explain how peoples are governed, on what authority, and within what limits. They describe and compare limited and unlimited governments. They state the grounds on which a government's power is rightly limited. They identify and describe human rights abuses, including the oppression of religious, ethnic, and political groups, and they state what makes such treatment a wrong and not a policy. They identify governments as rule by one, by few, or by many. They compare how societies organize government and how those governments function. They identify the historical origins of democratic forms of government. They describe and compare the roles and responsibilities of citizens in various societies, including the United States, and they explain how the opportunity to take part in political life varies. They explain the duty of civic participation and the relations among rights, responsibilities, duties, and freedoms under representative government. They describe a governmental or democratic process, such as voting, due process, or a caucus, by working through a simulation or model of it.

Elements

  • L5.1 Describe and compare a limited and an unlimited government, such as a constitutional and a totalitarian one.
  • L5.2 State the grounds on which a government's power is rightly limited.
  • L5.3 Identify and describe an instance of human rights abuse, including the oppression of a religious, ethnic, or political group, and state what makes the treatment a wrong.
  • L5.4 Identify a government as rule by one, by few, or by many, and compare how two societies organize government and how each functions.
  • L5.5 Identify the historical origins of democratic forms of government.
  • L5.6 Describe and compare the roles and responsibilities of citizens in two societies, including the United States, and explain how the opportunity to take part in political life differs between them.
  • L5.7 Explain the duty of civic participation, and the relations among rights, responsibilities, duties, and freedoms under representative government.
  • L5.8 Describe a governmental or democratic process such as voting, due process, or a caucus by taking part in a simulation or working through a model of it.

Epistemic Anchor

This lodestar teaches the ground of authority and of its limits as part of what a student learns. An office is held from God and for a purpose. Because its power is delegated, it is not unlimited. Oppression is a wrong for two reasons. Those oppressed bear the image of God. The ruler who oppresses has gone beyond the commission by which he holds any power at all. This lodestar also teaches that the consent of the governed is the ordinary means by which a republic appoints those who hold authority. Consent is not the source of that authority. The American constitutional form is taught as a wise and defensible arrangement. Its own founding documents ground unalienable rights in the Creator who gives them.

A citizen's duties are real and owed. Honor, taxes, and obedience are owed to those who hold office. They are owed for the sake of God, who established the office, not because the officeholder has earned them. The account that sets the duty also sets its limit. A subject commanded to sin must refuse, respectfully and at his own cost. Daniel served Babylonian and Persian kings faithfully for a lifetime and refused them at one point. That is the ordinary pattern, not the heroic exception.

The simulation element belongs here because a process is understood by going through it. A student who has counted votes, sat through a deliberation, or worked a case through due process knows what the procedure protects. A description alone cannot teach him that.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A governance analysis that ends in a stated judgment. The student compares two societies on how each is governed and what each asks of a citizen. He states the ground on which the power of any government is limited. He applies that ground to one documented case of oppression, saying what was violated and why it was a wrong. He delivers the analysis in writing, or he articulates and defends it within a simulated deliberation. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Sorting governments as limited or unlimited, with a stated reason. Identifying rule by one, few, or many. Short statements of the ground of a limit on power. Simulations of voting, due process, and deliberation, each closed by a brief written account of what the process protected.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Forms of ruleCompares two governments on how each is structured and how each actually functions, and accounts for the difference.Compares two governments accurately on structure and function.Describes two governments without comparing them, or compares them by label.Misstates how a government is organized, or offers approval in place of description.
Ground of authority and limitStates a ground for the limits of government power, reasons from it consistently, and applies it to a case that tests it.States a ground for limiting government power and reasons from it.Asserts that power should be limited without giving a ground, or states a ground and does not use it.Treats power as justifying itself, or treats rights as claims that need no ground.
Judgment about wrongEstablishes what was done, states what makes it a wrong, and keeps the two steps distinct.Identifies an abuse accurately and states the ground on which it is judged.Names an abuse and condemns it without stating a ground.Reports an atrocity as one policy among others, or condemns without establishing what happened.
Citizenship and dutyExplains a citizen's duties, the relations among rights and duties, and the point at which obedience meets a higher obligation.Explains civic duty and the relations among rights, responsibilities, and freedoms.Lists rights without duties, or duties without their ground.Treats citizenship as entitlement only, or as unconditional obedience.
Lodestar 6 · Culture, Institutions, and What Peoples Build

Lodestar Statement

Students explain what a culture is, what every society builds, and how cultures act on one another. They identify the traits that define a culture and a culture region. They define a multicultural society and analyze the experiences and contributions of the groups within one. They identify instances of conflict and of cooperation among cultures and account for each. They identify the institutions basic to all societies, including government, economic, educational, and religious institutions. They account for why the same institutions recur in every society. They compare an institution across societies. They analyze how an institution sustains itself over time and what its failure costs a society. They identify the means and drivers of cultural diffusion and change, including trade, travel, war, improvements in communication and transportation, and economic development. They analyze how improved communication technology has affected interaction among cultures. They identify the effects of diffusion on individuals and societies.

Elements

  • L6.1 Identify the common traits that define a culture and mark out a culture region.
  • L6.2 Define a multicultural society, and analyze the experiences and contributions of the groups within one.
  • L6.3 Identify an instance of conflict and an instance of cooperation between cultures, and account for each.
  • L6.4 Identify the institutions basic to all societies, including government, economic, educational, and religious institutions.
  • L6.5 Account for why the same institutions recur in every society that has been studied.
  • L6.6 Compare one institution across two societies and describe how its character differs.
  • L6.7 Analyze how an institution sustains itself over time, and what the failure of an institution costs a society.
  • L6.8 Identify the means and drivers of cultural diffusion and change, including trade, travel, war, communication, transportation, and economic development, and identify the effects of diffusion on individuals and on societies.
  • L6.9 Analyze how an improvement in communication technology affected interaction and exchange among cultures.

Epistemic Anchor

Every society that has been studied builds the same basic institutions. This lodestar makes the reason for that part of what a student learns. Government, teaching, exchange, the household, and worship recur because the same kind of creature builds every society. He is made to rule under God, to raise children, to hand on what he knows, and to worship. The recurrence of institutions is therefore evidence about human nature, not a coincidence. Scripture's earliest account of culture already holds these elements. A city, herds, metalwork, and music appear within a few verses of one another.

Comparison needs a measure, or it is only a list. A student who compares an institution across two societies should be able to say that one arrangement served children well and another destroyed them. He should say it on grounds he can state and defend. This lodestar rests on a plain premise. A culture is something people make, and what people make can be made well or badly. A student must describe another culture accurately and charitably. Accuracy does not require him to treat every arrangement as equally good.

War spread culture alongside trade and travel, and much of what passed between peoples passed through conquest. This lodestar states that plainly. A student learns to hold it without praising conquest. He also learns not to conclude that nothing good ever came through a bad means.

Assessment Signature

Summative. An institutional comparison. The student takes one institution basic to all societies and compares it across two societies under study. He accounts for why the institution exists at all. He explains how the character of each version differs and how each sustained itself. He identifies one thing one culture took from the other and the means by which it passed. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Identifying the traits of a culture and its culture region. Lists of the institutions of two societies. Short accounts of one instance of conflict and one of cooperation. Tracing how a single artifact, word, or technology spread, including one carried by a new means of communication.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Cultural analysisIdentifies the traits that define a culture and explains what holds them together as one culture.Identifies defining traits and culture regions accurately.Lists features of a culture without saying what makes them a culture.Reduces a culture to food, dress, and holidays.
Institutions and their groundAccounts for why an institution recurs in every society, and reasons from that account to what the institution is for.States why institutions such as government, education, and worship are found in every society.Notes the recurrence without accounting for it.Treats the recurrence as coincidence, or does not notice it.
Comparison with a stated measureCompares an institution across two societies and evaluates each on grounds he states and defends.Compares an institution accurately and gives a supported evaluation.Compares accurately but declines to evaluate, or evaluates without grounds.Ranks cultures by preference, or holds that no comparison is possible.
Diffusion and causationTraces something that moved between cultures, names the means, and weighs what the exchange cost and gained.Identifies the means and drivers of diffusion and their effects accurately.Names means of diffusion without tracing an instance.Treats cultures as sealed off from one another, or treats all exchange as wholly good or wholly bad.
Lodestar 7 · Worship, Art, and What Peoples Love

Lodestar Statement

Students explain what a people worshiped and what it made, and how the two bear on each other. They explain the relationship among the religious ideas, the philosophical ideas, and the culture of a society, and they say which shapes which. They explain the significance of religious holidays and observances, stating what each claims and not only what it marks. They state what another people believed about God, the world, and human beings in terms its own adherents would recognize. They explain the relationship between a society and its architecture, art, music, and literature. They describe how the questions and pressures of an age bear on what its artists make. They identify works that carry universal themes such as religion, justice, and the passage of time. They account for why such themes recur among peoples who never met. They trace a line from what a people worshiped to something it built, legislated, or made.

Elements

  • L7.1 Explain the relationship among the religious ideas, the philosophical ideas, and the culture of a society, and say which shapes which.
  • L7.2 Explain the significance of a religious holiday or observance, stating what it claims and not only when it falls.
  • L7.3 State what another people believed about God, the world, and human beings, in terms its own adherents would recognize.
  • L7.4 Explain the relationship between a society and its architecture, art, music, and literature.
  • L7.5 Describe how the questions and pressures of an age bear on what its artists make.
  • L7.6 Identify a work of art, music, or literature that carries a universal theme such as religion, justice, or the passage of time, and account for why the theme recurs among peoples who never met.
  • L7.7 Trace a line from what a people worshiped to something it built, legislated, or made.

Epistemic Anchor

In this content the direction of explanation matters most, and this lodestar sets it. A people's culture follows from its gods. Its gods do not come from its culture. Temples are usually the largest buildings a society raises. Law codes are usually issued in the name of a god. Nearly every people has ordered its calendar around what it believed it owed to heaven. A student should ask what a people believed about God, and then what it built and legislated as a result. That is better history, not only more devout history. Scripture states how this works. Those who make idols become like them. People who suppress the knowledge of the true God redirect their worship; they do not abandon it.

The hardest discipline in this course is stating accurately what someone else believes, and this lodestar scores it. A student may learn to state what a Roman, a Hindu, or a Muslim held, in terms that person would accept. He will need that skill when he has such a neighbor. He learns it without being told that beliefs are interchangeable. Accuracy is not agreement. This lodestar teaches the Christian faith plainly and as true. For that reason accuracy costs nothing, because there is no need to weaken another position in order to answer it. The rubric scores accuracy and reasoning. It does not score the student's own profession.

Certain themes recur in the art of peoples who never met, and religion is first among them. This lodestar claims that fact as it stands. Recurrence is what one would expect if the same Maker made every people and wrote something of his law on every conscience. A student who notices the recurrence and asks why it exists is asking one of the most useful questions in the humanities.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A study of worship and works, written or presented. The student takes one society and traces a line from what it worshiped to something it built, legislated, or made. He states that society's belief about God, the world, and human beings in terms its own adherents would recognize. He accounts for one universal theme its art shares with a people it never met. Scored by this lodestar's rubric, which scores the accuracy of the account and the quality of the reasoning, not the student's own confession.

Formative. Short statements of another people's belief, checked for accuracy against a primary source from that people. Brief accounts of a holiday or observance that state what it claims. Readings of a building or an artwork against what the society honored. Identifying one theme across two unrelated cultures.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Accuracy of statementStates another people's convictions in terms its own adherents would accept, and distinguishes what they held from what later observers said they held.States another people's convictions accurately and without distortion.States them in a weakened, partial, or modernized form.Presents a caricature, or presents the convictions as interchangeable with everyone else's.
Direction of explanationTraces a specific line from what a people worshiped to something it built, legislated, or made, and shows what the connection rests on.Explains how religious and philosophical ideas bear on a culture, and states the direction of influence.Notes that religion and culture are related without saying how or in which direction.Treats worship as a custom a society happened to have.
Art and societyAccounts for what a work was for in its society, and for how the questions of its age shaped what its maker could attempt.Explains the relationship between a society and its art accurately.Describes a work without connecting it to the society that produced it.Only notes that art exists, or judges it only by present taste.
Universal themesIdentifies a theme that recurs among unconnected peoples and gives a reasoned account of why it recurs.Identifies a recurring theme across two cultures and supports the identification.Asserts a shared theme without evidence from either work.Denies that anything recurs, or asserts that all cultures say the same thing.
Lodestar 8 · Truthful Communication and Prudent Judgment

Lodestar Statement

Students report what they have found truthfully and decide well under uncertainty. They use the terms of the discipline correctly. They carry a main idea and its supporting ideas into written and spoken work grounded in research. They express a position orally so that a listener can follow the reasoning and not only the conclusion. They produce written and visual work, including reports, journal entries, graphic organizers, outlines, and bibliographies. They cite sources accurately and distinguish paraphrase from plagiarism. They take part in civil discourse on questions that have more than one defensible position, and they state another's position accurately before answering it. They work a problem through a full process: identifying it, gathering information, listing options, and weighing their advantages and disadvantages. They choose and carry out a solution, judge afterward whether it worked, and say what they would do differently.

Elements

  • L8.1 Use the terms of history, geography, economics, and government correctly and without inflating them.
  • L8.2 Carry a main idea and its supporting ideas into a written or spoken piece grounded in research.
  • L8.3 Express a position orally so that a listener can follow the reasoning and not only the conclusion.
  • L8.4 Produce written and visual work, including a report, a journal entry, a graphic organizer, an outline, and a bibliography.
  • L8.5 Cite sources accurately, and distinguish paraphrase from plagiarism.
  • L8.6 Take part in civil discourse on a question that has more than one defensible position, stating another's position accurately before answering it.
  • L8.7 Work a problem through identification, information gathering, and the listing and weighing of options with their advantages and disadvantages.
  • L8.8 Choose and carry out a solution, then judge afterward whether it worked and say what would be done differently.

Epistemic Anchor

Citation is a form of truth telling, and this lodestar treats it as one. Passing off another person's sentence as one's own is both theft and false witness. That is why attribution appears in a lodestar and not only in a conduct policy. It is also why the element pairs citation with the distinction between paraphrase and plagiarism. A student who gives a source what is owed to it practices, on a small matter, the honesty this course asks of him on large ones.

This lodestar requires civil discourse in a specific sense. A student holds a position and treats the person who holds another with respect. A question that has an answer does not become a matter of taste because people disagree about it. What keeps respect from sliding into indifference is a rule: the student first states another position accurately and then answers it. Charity here works as a rule of evidence, not only as a courtesy.

The decision process ends with judging whether the chosen solution worked. That last step is the one most often dropped, and it is the one that forms the student. A student who must return to his own decision and say plainly whether it worked is being trained in prudence. Prudence is a virtue with a structure. It is not another word for caution. Scripture commends counting the cost before building, and it commends looking honestly at what one has built.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A researched recommendation. The student takes a problem faced by a society under study and works it through the full process. He recommends a course of action and states its advantages and disadvantages. In discussion, he first states an opposing position accurately in its own terms and then defends his recommendation against it. Afterward, he judges the recommendation against what actually happened or against a criterion he set in advance. He delivers the work in writing and orally, with sources cited. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Checks on terms used in context. Outline and bibliography exercises. Paraphrase set against plagiarism. Short structured discussions that require restating a position before replying. Weighing options in small cases.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Attribution and honestyParaphrases in his own words, quotes deliberately, and cites accurately and completely throughout.Distinguishes paraphrase from quotation and cites sources accurately.Paraphrases too close to the source's wording, or cites incompletely.Uses source material without attribution.
Organization and termsOrganizes a main idea and its support so that a reader or listener can follow the reasoning, and uses the discipline's terms exactly.Presents a main idea with supporting ideas clearly and uses terms correctly.Presents information without a controlling idea, or uses terms loosely.Cannot be followed, or misuses the terms of the discipline.
Conduct in discourseStates another's position in a form its holder would accept, answers that version of it, and holds his own position without contempt.Represents another position accurately and responds to it.Represents another position in a weakened form, or responds without representing it.Answers a position no one advanced, or abandons his own position to avoid disagreement.
Decision and reviewWorks the full process, weighs options against stated criteria, and judges the outcome candidly, including where he was wrong.Works the process through to a choice and judges the result.Reaches a decision without weighing alternatives, or omits the judgment of the result.States a preference in place of a process.
Reference
TEKS Correspondence
LodestarTEKS strandWhat this lodestar carries
Lodestar 1(c)(19)(A)-(F)Primary and secondary sources and their use to acquire information about world cultures; analysis by sequencing, categorizing, cause and effect, comparison, contrast, main idea, summary, generalization, prediction, and inference; organization and interpretation of information from outlines, reports, databases, and visuals including graphs, charts, timelines, and maps; differing points of view about an issue or topic; a claim supported by evidence and reasoning; and evaluation of historical and contemporary sources for validity, credibility, bias, and accuracy.
Lodestar 2(c)(1)(A)-(B)The characteristics of societies traced to the historical events or factors that produced them, including colonization, immigration, and trade, and the historical background of a society evaluated for the relationship between past conflict and later conditions.
Lodestar 2(c)(2)(A)-(B)The historical influence of individuals and groups on societies, and their social, political, economic, and cultural contributions, past and present.
Lodestar 2(c)(18)(A)-(C)Scientific discoveries, technological innovations, and the scientists and inventors who shaped the world; the bearing of resources, economic factors, and political decisions on the use of technology; and predictions about the effects of future discoveries and innovations.
Lodestar 3(c)(3)(A)-(D)The geographic factors responsible for patterns of population; the influence of human migration on the character of places and regions; the location of major physical and human features including landforms, water bodies, and urban centers; and the location of the major world countries of each region.
Lodestar 3(c)(4)(A)-(B)The geographic factors responsible for the location of economic activities, and the geographic factors bearing on a society's political relationships, including location, physical features, transportation corridors and barriers, and the distribution of natural resources.
Lodestar 3(c)(5)(A)-(C)The effect of physical processes such as earthquakes and climate on people, the ways people have adapted to the physical environment, and the ways people have modified it, including mining, irrigation, and transportation infrastructure.
Lodestar 3(c)(20)(A)-(D)Geographic questions of location and significance, including by latitude and longitude; questions about distributions and patterns shown on maps, graphs, and charts; comparison of regions and countries using such data; and the creation and interpretation of sketch maps, thematic maps, graphs, and charts.
Lodestar 4(c)(6)(A)-(C)The bearing of the factors of production, namely natural resources, labor, capital, and entrepreneurs, on the economies of societies; the problems arising when a factor is in short supply; and the effect of the distribution of resources on international trade and economic interdependence.
Lodestar 4(c)(7)(A)-(C)Comparison of the ways societies organize the production and distribution of goods and services; comparison of free enterprise, socialist, and communist economies including the benefits of the United States free enterprise system; and the importance of ethics to a functioning free enterprise system.
Lodestar 4(c)(8)(A)-(B)Agricultural, retail, manufacturing, and service industry defined and exemplified, and levels of economic development described using indicators including life expectancy, gross domestic product, gross domestic product per capita, and literacy.
Lodestar 5(c)(9)(A)-(C)Limited and unlimited governments described and compared, including constitutional and totalitarian forms; the reasons for limiting the power of government; and examples of human rights abuses by governments of either kind, including the oppression of religious, ethnic, and political groups.
Lodestar 5(c)(10)(A)-(C)Governments identified as rule by one, few, or many; comparison of how societies organize government and how those governments function; and the historical origins of democratic forms of government.
Lodestar 5(c)(11)(A)-(B)The roles and responsibilities of citizens in various societies, including the United States, and the varying opportunity of citizens to participate in and influence the political process.
Lodestar 5(c)(12)(A)-(B)The duty of civic participation in societies with representative governments, and the relations among rights, responsibilities, and duties in such societies.
Lodestar 5(c)(22)(A)Governmental and democratic processes such as voting, due process, and caucuses described through simulations and models.
Lodestar 6(c)(13)(A)-(D)The common traits defining cultures and culture regions; the definition of a multicultural society; the experiences and contributions of diverse groups within multicultural societies; and examples of conflict and cooperation between and among cultures.
Lodestar 6(c)(14)(A)-(C)The institutions basic to all societies, including government, economic, educational, and religious institutions; comparison of those institutions across societies; and the efforts by which institutions sustain themselves over time.
Lodestar 6(c)(15)(A)-(D)The means of cultural diffusion including trade, travel, and war; the factors influencing cultural change including improvements in communication, transportation, and economic development; the effect of improved communication technology among cultures; and the effects of diffusion on individuals and world societies.
Lodestar 7(c)(16)(A)-(C)The relationships between societies and their architecture, art, music, and literature; the influence of the issues of an age on creative expression; and works of art, music, and literature conveying universal themes such as religion, justice, and the passage of time.
Lodestar 7(c)(17)(A)-(B)The relationship among religious ideas, philosophical ideas, and cultures, and the significance of religious holidays and observances in various societies.
Lodestar 8(c)(21)(A)-(F)Correct use of social studies terminology; main and supporting ideas incorporated into verbal and written communication based on research; ideas expressed orally from research and experience; written and visual material including journal entries, reports, graphic organizers, outlines, and bibliographies; effective written communication including proper citation to avoid plagiarism; and foundational language skills applied to civil discourse on topics carrying multiple perspectives.
Lodestar 8(c)(22)(B)The problem-solving and decision-making process in full: identifying a problem, gathering information, listing and considering options, weighing advantages and disadvantages, choosing and implementing a solution, and evaluating its effectiveness.
ESO Mapping
LodestarESOHow the lodestar exercises it
Lodestar 12.2Makes the weighing of evidence, not the recall of a narrative, the object of mastery.
Lodestar 12.6Equips independent inquiry: the student finds a source, tests it, and says what it can bear.
Lodestar 11.3.1Forms attention to authorship, occasion, and audience, on which sound reading of Scripture depends.
Lodestar 22.2Requires a causal claim about the past to be supported from evidence, not asserted from sequence.
Lodestar 22.3Requires one explanation to be carried across history, economics, and technology.
Lodestar 21.4.2Makes human agency and accountability an object of study, applying what Scripture teaches about human nature to the record of what people have done.
Lodestar 21.8.2Treats invention and building as the work of stewards placed over creation.
Lodestar 31.8.2Treats the modification of an environment as the work of stewards holding a commission over creation.
Lodestar 32.2Requires a claim about a settlement pattern to be supported from data the student has read or produced.
Lodestar 32.3Connects physical geography to economics and to political history within one explanation.
Lodestar 42.2Requires an economic comparison to rest on evidence about two societies, not on definitions.
Lodestar 42.14Introduces the range of industries and occupations by which people earn a living.
Lodestar 41.8.6Treats ordinary trades and enterprise as honorable callings, not as lesser alternatives to ministry.
Lodestar 54.3.2Grounds the respect owed to those in authority in the reason Scripture gives for it, and marks its limit.
Lodestar 54.2.1Makes the image of God the stated ground on which the mistreatment of a people is judged a wrong.
Lodestar 52.2Requires a judgment about a government to be reasoned from a stated ground, not asserted.
Lodestar 61.4.2Uses the recurrence of institutions to teach what Scripture says about human nature and God's purposes for it.
Lodestar 61.7.5Requires a student to say, on stated grounds, what makes a community or institution healthy or unhealthy.
Lodestar 64.2.2Requires another people to be described accurately and its contributions acknowledged, which is respect put into practice.
Lodestar 62.3Connects institutional analysis to the geography, economics, and government treated elsewhere in the set.
Lodestar 71.4.1Calls for plain teaching of what the school confesses about God and his works, since an account of another people's belief requires the school's own account to be stated.
Lodestar 72.8Trains the attention that appreciation of art requires, by having the student account for what a society's art was for.
Lodestar 72.9Builds the capacity to read enduring works closely enough to be formed by them, not only informed about them.
Lodestar 74.2.2Requires another people's convictions to be stated in terms they would accept, which is respect practiced as a rule of evidence.
Lodestar 82.10Makes effective written communication a directly assessed capacity across several forms of work.
Lodestar 82.4Requires acquired knowledge to be brought to bear on a problem through a full decision process.
Lodestar 84.3.1Requires a person who holds another position to be answered in terms he would accept, which is respectful engagement practiced under pressure.
Lodestar 85.3.2Requires a student to return to a decision that may not have worked and account for it, so that failure becomes instructive and not merely painful.