Internal

Open Source Document

Epistemic Foundation

English language arts at Enlightium begins with the relational triune God, who exists as three Persons in one essence and communicates by nature. God created human beings in His image with the capacity to receive Him and His will through verbal discourse and communicate meaningfully with others. Language is, therefore, a gift from God that people should use truthfully and responsibly to love Him and serve others. In this way, meaning does not originate in a reader’s response but in the author’s intention: an author communicates meaning through a text, and that meaning directs and constrains how the reader should interpret it. Readers develop their understanding of what is communicated rather than create its meaning through their own experiences or preferences.

Students should therefore interpret a text through careful attention to its language, structure, genre, and context. They should distinguish between an understanding of what an author communicates and their own evaluation of its claims or applications in their lives. Because authors and readers are sinful and finite, both can make mistakes or encounter additional evidence; students should support their interpretations with textual evidence and remain willing to correct misunderstandings. Scripture, as God’s Word, is the governing authority for evaluating human claims and the responsible use of language. As in every discipline, learning begins in the fear of the Lord. Students approach reading as people created by God, addressed through His Word, and accountable to Him for how they understand and respond to others.

Assumptions Refused

English language arts at Enlightium, therefore, rejects four unbiblical assumptions carried over from secular science education. The corresponding chapter in the state framework reflects all four assumptions. Each assumption is rejected and replaced with an alternative grounded in the epistemic anchor above.

First, Enlightium rejects the assumption that academic success and workforce preparation are the primary purposes of English language arts. As the epistemic foundation states, the primary purpose of learning to read and write is to glorify God and equip students to love Him and serve their neighbors wisely. Higher education and employment are important contexts for applying reading and writing to the glory of God and wise service, but they do not determine the ultimate purpose of English language arts.

Second, Enlightium rejects the assumption that readers create a text’s meaning through their engagement with a text. Meaning resides with the authorial intent, and readers develop an understanding of that meaning through the text and relevant objective factors associated with it, like authorial textual and historical contexts. This follows from the epistemic foundation, in which God confronts humanity through language so that we may understand and be understood, thereby establishing love and faithful relationships. Thus, Enlightium’s instruction should teach students to support their interpretations with evidence from the text’s language, structure, and other objective contextual factors. An interpretation is accurate when it faithfully represents what the author communicates, and an application is strong when it draws logically from the authorial meaning to the student’s context today.

Third, Enlightium rejects the practice of prioritizing personal connections over textual evidence. Students should establish what a text communicates before relating it to their own experiences. Personal responses and applications are valuable when they follow from an accurate understanding of the text. Instruction should assess personal responses according to their reasoning and textual support, rather than originality or applications alone. Personal responses can help students recognize a text’s relevance to their lives and contemporary culture, but they do not establish its original meaning. Enlightium rejects the order that places personal connection ahead of textual evidence. Students learn that their own dignity and worth come from God as His image bearers and not by their own interpretations nor society’s judgments.

Fourth, Enlightium rejects the assumption that independent criticism is the goal of reading instruction. Sixth-grade students learn to evaluate sources, identify errors in reasoning, and reject unsupported or false claims. They should also examine their own assumptions and remain willing to accept correction based on valid evidence and reasoning. Enlightium’s English language arts should develop discernment together with humility and receptiveness to truth. Independent criticism held out as a goal in itself produces a reader who examines every text but accepts no authority or counterclaim that can correct his or her own judgment.

Values Formed (WISE)

People communicate meaning to one another through language. Readers and writers, therefore, have responsibilities toward the people with whom they communicate. Readers should seek to understand an author accurately and represent the author’s meaning fairly. Writers should express their meaning clearly, with attention to their readers’ understanding. Clear communication is an expression of love for God and others, and, for this reason, it is a language skill to be developed. At this grade level, English language arts instruction should develop love of neighbor through careful reading, fair representation, and clear writing.

Sixth-grade students should develop the habit of establishing what an author communicates before considering their own constructive thoughts and emotional responses. They should distinguish interpretations supported by textual evidence from assumptions or personal experiences they bring to the text. Before evaluating another person’s position, they should describe it accurately in terms that person would recognize as fair. Assessment rubrics should evaluate these habits through students’ textual evidence, reasoning, and clarity. Students should not receive credit merely for matching an expected interpretation; their interpretations must be supported by the text.

The Lodestar Standards
Lodestar 1 · Reading for the Author's Meaning

Lodestar Statement

Students read to recover what an author meant. They set a purpose for reading and sustain attention on the texts they read. They question, predict, and infer from evidence. They paraphrase, summarize, and compare texts without distorting them. They explain an author's purpose and message and how a text's structure serves that purpose. They distinguish what a text states from what it implies. They notice when their understanding has failed and repair it. They respond in writing and in discussion in terms answerable to the text, in a register fitted to the occasion.

Elements

  • L1.1 Set a purpose for reading, adjust pace and attention to that purpose, and sustain attention on a chosen text over time.
  • L1.2 Question a text before, during, and after reading, to test a reading rather than to confirm one.
  • L1.3 Predict from text features, genre, and structure, then confirm or correct the prediction against what the text says.
  • L1.4 Explain an author's purpose and message, and how the structure of a text serves that purpose.
  • L1.5 Draw an inference, name the evidence for it, and distinguish what a text states from what it implies.
  • L1.6 Paraphrase, summarize, and compare texts without distorting meaning or changing which ideas the author made primary and which secondary.
  • L1.7 Respond to a text in terms answerable to what the author wrote, in a register, vocabulary, and voice fitted to the occasion.
  • L1.8 Notice when understanding has failed, repair it, and revise a stated response when further evidence from the text requires it.

Epistemic Anchor

This lodestar forms the habit of receiving a text. Each element lets the text correct the reader. A prediction is made so that the text can confirm or overturn it. A question tests a reading; it does not gather support for a reading already held. Repair belongs here because a reader who never notices he is lost has stopped attending to the page. A sixth grader learns that he can be wrong about a text and can find it out. That is a moral capacity as well as a mental one.

This lodestar also orders a reader's response. The text is answered first, and the reader's own connections follow. Connection to experience, to other texts, and to the world is a required part of reading, and this lodestar claims it in full. Those connections are held to what the author actually wrote. A student should be able to say which part of his response came from the page and which part he supplied. Every other lodestar in the set depends on that habit. Sound reading of Scripture asks the same habit of him.

This lodestar claims sustained independent reading as the formation of a reader. What a student gives his attention to shapes what he learns to love. Teaching a reader therefore includes teaching judgment about what rewards attention. The measure is that judgment; quantity of reading alone does not show it. On this ground, enduring and classical literature holds a settled place in what students read.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A written interpretive essay or an oral defense on a text not discussed in class. The student articulates what the author meant and supports that reading from the text. He identifies at least one point where further evidence corrected his first reading. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Low-stakes checks on inference supported by evidence; on paraphrase that keeps the author's emphasis and order of importance; and on the line between what a text states and what the reader has supplied.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Fidelity to the textStates what the author meant in the author's own terms, and shows where the text rules out a plausible alternative reading.States the author's meaning accurately and does not put a preferred reading in its place.Reading is broadly accurate but drifts in places toward what the reader expected to find.Reports an impression as the text's meaning, or restates the text without saying what it means.
Evidence handlingSelects the evidence that bears most directly, quotes accurately, and keeps the context that gives the quotation its force.Supports each claim with relevant, accurately quoted evidence.Cites evidence unevenly, or quotes accurately but out of context.Assertion stands in for evidence, or evidence is listed without being used.
Inference and implicationDraws an inference the text supports, says what makes it an inference rather than a statement, and claims no more than the text supports.Distinguishes what the text states from what it implies, and supports both.Blurs statement and implication, or presents a strong implication as though the text had said it.Declines to infer at all, or infers freely without reference to the text.
Self-correctionIdentifies where a first reading was wrong and names what in the text corrected it.Revises a reading when the text requires it and says that he has done so.Adjusts a reading without saying what prompted the change.Holds a first reading against the evidence, or abandons it without reason.
Lodestar 2 · Inquiry, Evidence, and Honest Testimony

Lodestar Statement

Students conduct inquiry and weigh claims and evidence honestly. They frame and refine a question. They gather information from a variety of sources, distinguish primary sources from secondary, and synthesize what they find. They examine sources for reliability, credibility, bias, and faulty reasoning. They identify the claim of a text that advances a position, the kinds of evidence it offers, and the audience it addresses. They distinguish a rhetorical device from a logical fallacy. They represent and cite the words and reasoning of others truthfully. They communicate their results in a mode fitted to the occasion.

Elements

  • L2.1 Frame a question for inquiry, plan the inquiry, and refine the question when a first round of answers requires it.
  • L2.2 Gather relevant information from a variety of sources, and distinguish primary sources from secondary.
  • L2.3 Synthesize what several sources say into an account that represents each of them fairly.
  • L2.4 Identify the claim of a text that advances a position, the kinds of evidence offered for it, and the audience it addresses.
  • L2.5 Examine a source for reliability, credibility, and bias, and name what in the source shows it.
  • L2.6 Distinguish a rhetorical device from a logical fallacy, and treat hyperbole, emotional appeal, and stereotype as questions of reasoning, not of style.
  • L2.7 Distinguish paraphrase from plagiarism, and cite sources accurately in an appropriate academic form.
  • L2.8 Communicate the results of an inquiry in a written, oral, or multimodal form fitted to the audience and occasion.

Epistemic Anchor

Source work trains a student in honesty. To tell paraphrase from plagiarism is to tell the truth about whose words he is using. To examine a source for bias is to guard against being deceived. A rhetorical device persuades a neighbor. A logical fallacy manipulates him. A sixth grader who can name that difference has learned something he will use for the rest of his life.

This lodestar carries one requirement of its own. Before a student answers a position he does not hold, he states it in a form its holder would accept. This is charity applied as a rule of evidence. The school asks the same of its own writers when they engage a view it rejects. Fair engagement does not give a view equal standing as to truth. A student may conclude that a position is wrong. He may not defeat a version of it that nobody holds.

The pitch at this grade is modest. A sixth grader does not evaluate scholarship. He learns that a claim and its support have parts, and that the parts can be named. He learns that some sources are better than others, for reasons he can state. He learns that words belong to the people who wrote them.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A researched piece, written, oral, or multimodal, in which the student articulates a claim that answers a question he has refined. He synthesizes at least three sources of differing reliability. He states a position he does not hold in its strongest form before answering it. He attributes and cites his sources accurately. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Source examination exercises; checks that separate paraphrase from plagiarism; identification of claim, kind of evidence, and audience in short texts that advance a position; and naming a fallacy in a text that also uses legitimate persuasive force.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Source discriminationWeighs sources against one another, distinguishes primary from secondary, and states what makes each reliable or unreliable for this question.Distinguishes primary from secondary sources and identifies evident bias.Uses sources of uneven quality without noting the difference.Treats all sources as equal, or dismisses a source without stating grounds.
Fair representationStates an opposing position in a form its holder would accept, then answers that version of it.Represents an opposing position accurately and without distortion.Represents an opposing position in a weakened or partial form.Represents no opposing position, or represents one only in caricature.
Reasoning and fallacyNames a fallacy, explains why the reasoning fails, and distinguishes it from legitimate persuasive force in the same text.Distinguishes a rhetorical device from a logical fallacy correctly in most instances.Uses the terms but applies them inconsistently.Treats vivid language as proof, or treats every strong appeal as a fallacy.
AttributionParaphrases in his own sentence structure throughout, quotes by deliberate choice, and cites accurately and completely.Distinguishes paraphrase from quotation and cites sources.Paraphrase follows the source's wording too closely, or citation is incomplete.Source material appears without attribution.
Lodestar 3 · Narrative and the Human Person

Lodestar Statement

Students analyze how a narrative works and what it shows about human beings. They infer themes within and across texts from evidence. They analyze how a character's inward and outward responses develop a plot. They analyze plot elements, including non-linear order. They analyze how setting, including historical and cultural setting, shapes character and plot. They analyze how a playwright develops character through dialogue and staging. They distinguish what a narrative shows about a person from what it invites a reader to approve.

Elements

  • L3.1 Infer a theme from evidence in the text, and infer more than one where the text supports more than one.
  • L3.2 Trace a theme across two texts, and explain what each does with it differently.
  • L3.3 Analyze how a character's inward response and outward action bear on each other and move the plot.
  • L3.4 Analyze the parts of a plot, including rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution.
  • L3.5 Analyze the effect of a non-linear order, such as flashback, on what a reader knows and when he knows it.
  • L3.6 Analyze how setting, including a historical or cultural setting, shapes what a character does and what the plot makes possible.
  • L3.7 Analyze how a playwright builds a character through dialogue and staging rather than through narration.
  • L3.8 Distinguish what a narrative shows about a person from what the text invites a reader to approve.

Epistemic Anchor

Narrative sets out human action so that it can be understood. A sixth grader reading a story watches a person choose. When this lodestar asks how a character's inward and outward responses move a plot, it makes a claim about human beings. What a person is inwardly issues in what he does. What he does has consequences he did not choose and cannot undo. Setting shapes a character without determining him. So a student analyzes the influence of setting. He also reads a character's action as a response, not as a product of circumstance.

The last element keeps a reader from two errors. One turns every story into a moral lesson. The other treats stories as saying nothing. A story shows; it does not always endorse. A reader who cannot tell depiction from approval falls into one error or the other, and both are common at this age. The rubric scores that distinction, not the verdict a student reaches. This is the rule throughout the set. It matters most here, because the conduct of characters in serious literature often tests the reader's own judgment.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A written or oral analysis of one narrative. The student states a theme and supports it from the structure of the plot and the development of a character. He explains how the setting bore on both. He states where the text shows conduct without commending it. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Theme statements tested against counter-evidence from the same text; plot mapping, including non-linear order; short comparisons of how two texts handle a shared theme; and scene work on how dialogue and staging carry characterization.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Theme and evidenceStates a theme the whole work supports, tests it against a passage that resists it, and holds or refines it accordingly.States a defensible theme and supports it with evidence from across the text.States a theme but supports it from one or two convenient passages.Reports the subject of the text as its theme, or states a theme with no support.
Character and causationTraces the line from a character's inward response to his action to its consequence, and notes where the text leaves that line unstated.Explains how a character's responses move the plot forward.Describes a character and describes a plot without connecting them.Treats character as a list of traits, or treats events as unrelated to anyone's choices.
Structure and settingExplains how setting bears on character and plot, and how the order of events, including any departure from sequence, controls what a reader knows and when.Identifies plot elements accurately and explains how setting bears on character and plot.Identifies plot elements but treats setting as backdrop.Retells events in order without analysis of structure.
Judgment and restraintDistinguishes what the narrative shows from what it endorses, and says how the text signals the difference.Does not confuse a character's conduct with the text's approval of it.Reads approval into depiction, or declines to say what the text conveys at all.Reduces the narrative to a moral, or denies that it conveys anything.
Lodestar 4 · Craft and the Making of Meaning

Lodestar Statement

Students analyze how an author's choices make meaning. They describe how figurative language achieves a purpose. They identify literary devices, including omniscient and limited point of view, and explain what each makes possible. They analyze how an author's use of language produces mood and voice. They analyze how print and graphic features serve a purpose. They analyze the effect of meter and of structural elements, such as line breaks, across poetic forms.

Elements

  • L4.1 Describe how a figure of speech, such as metaphor or personification, achieves a purpose that plain statement would not.
  • L4.2 Identify the point of view of a text as omniscient or limited, and explain what that choice lets a reader know and what it withholds.
  • L4.3 Identify other literary devices at work in a text, and say what each accomplishes there.
  • L4.4 Analyze how an author's word choice and sentence construction produce mood.
  • L4.5 Analyze how an author's language produces a voice, and distinguish the voice of a text from the person who wrote it.
  • L4.6 Analyze how print and graphic features serve an author's purpose.
  • L4.7 Analyze the effect of meter in a poem, and explain what the meter does to the sense.
  • L4.8 Analyze the effect of structural elements, such as line breaks, across different poetic forms.

Epistemic Anchor

Craft shows that a meaning was made by someone. Every figure, choice of narrator, and line break is a decision by a person who wanted a reader to see something a certain way. When the author cannot be asked, the analysis of craft is the ordinary way to his intention. So this lodestar does not sit on top of comprehension as decoration. It is how a careful reader reaches what Lodestar 1 asks him to recover.

A metaphor does work that its paraphrase cannot do. A student who learns this has learned something true about language: form and meaning cannot be pulled apart. This bears on how he reads Scripture. Its poetry is poetry, and its parables are parables. Honoring figure and device where a text uses them follows from reading for the author's intention.

This lodestar also holds the distinction between a text's voice and its author. A narrator is not the author. A reader who forgets this will credit a writer with every opinion his characters hold. A reader who overcorrects will conclude that no text has a view at all. The rubric scores both as failures.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A close analysis of a short poem or prose passage. The student explains how specific choices of figure, point of view, and language produce the effect the text has. He states what would be lost if one named choice were made differently. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Exercises that replace a figure with plain statement and account for what is lost; identification of point of view and of what it withholds; scansion and line-break analysis on short poems; and comparison of passages for mood and voice.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Attention to the particularQuotes the exact words that carry the effect and explains their work phrase by phrase.Identifies the specific language responsible for an effect.Points to a general passage rather than to the language that does the work.Names an effect without locating it in the text.
Effect and purposeExplains what a choice accomplishes, and shows by substituting another choice what would be lost.Explains what a device accomplishes in this text.Identifies a device and asserts an effect without explaining the connection.Labels devices without reference to what they do.
Point of view and voiceExplains what the chosen point of view withholds as well as what it grants, and distinguishes the text's voice from its author.Identifies point of view accurately and describes the voice of the text.Identifies point of view but treats voice as the author's own opinion.Confuses narrator with author, or treats the text as having no perspective.
Precision of termsUses the terms of craft exactly, keeping each term to its proper use.Uses the terms of craft correctly.Uses terms loosely or interchangeably.Misapplies the terms of craft.
Lodestar 5 · Genre, Form, and Purpose

Lodestar Statement

Students explain what different kinds of text are for and how form serves purpose. They show knowledge of literary genres and their characteristics. They analyze an informational text for its controlling idea or thesis and its supporting evidence. They also analyze the features that supply background and the text's organizational patterns. They analyze the characteristics of multimodal and digital texts. They explain why a given purpose calls for one form rather than another.

Elements

  • L5.1 Identify the genre of a text from its characteristics, and say what those characteristics are for.
  • L5.2 Show knowledge of literary genres and of what a reader may reasonably expect of each.
  • L5.3 Identify the controlling idea or thesis of an informational text and the evidence offered for it.
  • L5.4 Use the features of an informational text, such as an introduction, foreword, preface, references, or acknowledgments, to gain background before reading.
  • L5.5 Analyze the organizational pattern of an informational text, including definition, classification, and advantage and disadvantage.
  • L5.6 Explain how a chosen organizational pattern serves a writer's purpose better than another would.
  • L5.7 Analyze the characteristics of a multimodal or digital text, and how its several modes bear on one another.
  • L5.8 Explain why a given purpose calls for one form rather than another.

Epistemic Anchor

A genre is a set of expectations shared by a writer and a reader. It works because both accept it in advance. A student who knows what a genre promises can tell when a text has kept the promise and when it has quietly broken it. That is a capacity for judgment, not a matter of sorting. So this lodestar asks him to say what a genre's characteristics are for, not only to name them.

This lodestar centers on how form serves purpose. That focus separates it from Lodestar 4. Lodestar 4 asks how a sentence works. This lodestar asks why a kind of text exists and what its maker wanted. A student who asks that of an essay, a poem, a play, and a web page learns that no form is neutral. Each was built by someone who wanted something from the reader. This is the beginning of discernment for a student who will spend his life among texts designed to move him.

This lodestar claims knowledge of literary genres as a capacity a student can carry to any text. It does not fix which genres or texts are studied in a given year. A teacher may change a novel or a unit without changing this lodestar.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A comparative analysis of one question or subject treated in two different forms. The student explains what each form makes possible and what each cannot do. He explains why a writer with a given purpose would choose one over the other. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Genre identification justified from characteristics; identification of thesis and support in short informational texts; analysis of organizational pattern; and short readings of multimodal texts for how image, text, and arrangement work together.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Genre knowledgeIdentifies genre from its characteristics and explains what those characteristics do for a reader.Identifies genre accurately and names its characteristics.Identifies genre by subject matter rather than by characteristics.Misidentifies genre, or names it without reference to any characteristic.
Informational analysisLocates the controlling idea, judges whether the evidence offered is enough to carry it, and uses the text's features to establish context.Identifies the controlling idea and the evidence supporting it, and uses the text's features.Identifies a topic rather than a controlling idea, or ignores the supporting evidence.Summarizes content without identifying an idea or its support.
Structure and purposeExplains why the chosen pattern serves this purpose and what another pattern would lose.Identifies the organizational pattern and connects it to the writer's purpose.Identifies a pattern without connecting it to purpose.Does not identify a pattern.
Comparative judgmentExplains what each form makes possible and what it rules out, without ranking forms as such.Compares two forms accurately on what each can do.Compares two texts rather than two forms.Asserts a preference in place of an analysis.
Lodestar 6 · Composing for a Reader

Lodestar Statement

Students compose texts a reader can follow and trust. They plan by choosing a genre fitted to topic, purpose, and audience. They develop drafts with purposeful structure and specific detail. They revise for clarity, organization, style, and sentence variety. They edit for the conventions of standard English set for this grade. They publish for an audience. They compose literary and informational texts, texts that advance and support a claim, and correspondence, using the characteristics and craft of each.

Elements

  • L6.1 Plan a draft by choosing a genre fitted to topic, purpose, and audience.
  • L6.2 Organize a draft with an introduction, purposeful transitions, coherence within and across paragraphs, and a conclusion.
  • L6.3 Develop an idea with specific facts and details sufficient to carry it.
  • L6.4 Revise for clarity, development, organization, style, word choice, and sentence variety.
  • L6.5 Edit for sentence integrity: complete complex sentences, subject-verb agreement, and the avoidance of comma splices, run-ons, and fragments.
  • L6.6 Edit for the parts of speech and their relations, including consistent verb tense, conjunctive adverbs, prepositional phrases and their bearing on agreement, relative pronouns, and subordinating and correlative conjunctions.
  • L6.7 Edit for capitalization; for punctuation, including commas in complex sentences, with transitions, and with introductory elements; and for correct spelling, including commonly confused terms.
  • L6.8 Compose literary and informational texts, texts that advance and support a claim, and correspondence, and publish finished work for its intended audience.

Epistemic Anchor

Writing makes the writer understood by another person. So the conventions are not etiquette. A comma splice makes a reader do work the writer could have done for him. A sentence whose subject and verb disagree asks the reader to guess. Each is a small failure to love the reader. Scripture states the principle for speech, and it holds on the page: speech that cannot be understood fails the person it was meant to serve.

This lodestar claims the conventions of standard English for this grade in full. It states them as three elements rather than a single editing step. Each class of convention can then be taught, practiced, and checked on its own. Each is required.

Publication completes the sequence. A student writes differently when someone who did not have to read the piece will read it. Planning, drafting, and revision all serve that reader.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A portfolio of finished pieces in at least three of the four required forms. Each piece is carried from plan through revision to publication. Each is presented with the drafts that produced it, so that the process is shown, not just claimed. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Timed drafting for a stated audience; editing exercises on the named conventions, one class of convention at a time; revision passes with a single focus; and peer readings that report where a reader lost track.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Structure and coherenceOrganization serves the purpose of the piece, and each transition makes clear how the next part relates to the one before.Introduction, body, transitions, and conclusion are present and coherent.Structure is present, but paragraphs do not connect, or transitions are mechanical.No discernible organization; a reader cannot follow the sequence.
DevelopmentSpecific facts and details are chosen for what they show and are sufficient to carry the idea.The idea is developed with relevant, specific detail.Detail is present but general, or repeats rather than develops.Assertion without support, or length without content.
ConventionsSentences are complete, varied, and correctly punctuated; the named conventions are controlled; remaining errors are rare and do not affect meaning.The named conventions are generally controlled, and errors do not impede a reader.Recurring errors in agreement, sentence boundaries, or punctuation slow a reader.Errors in sentence boundaries and agreement make the meaning hard to recover.
RevisionDrafts show substantive reconsideration, and the writer can say what each change was for.Drafts show real revision beyond correction.Changes are limited to surface correction.Successive drafts are effectively identical.
Lodestar 7 · Words and Spoken Discourse

Lodestar Statement

Students use words precisely and speak and listen well with others. They determine a word's meaning, origin, and use from reference resources, from context, and from Greek and Latin roots. They listen to understand what was actually said, and they ask questions that clarify it. They follow and give oral instructions with multiple steps. They give an organized presentation that takes a stance and holds it. They take part in student-led discussion: they draw out other members, take notes on what was said, and identify where the group agrees and where it does not.

Elements

  • L7.1 Use print or digital resources to determine a word's meaning, syllabication, pronunciation, origin, and part of speech.
  • L7.2 Use context, including definition, analogy, and example, to clarify an unfamiliar word.
  • L7.3 Determine the meaning and usage of academic English words built on Greek and Latin roots.
  • L7.4 Listen to understand what was actually said, and ask a question that clarifies rather than redirects.
  • L7.5 Follow and give oral instructions with multiple steps.
  • L7.6 Give an organized presentation that takes a stance and holds a position, with control of eye contact, rate, volume, enunciation, gesture, and the conventions of spoken language.
  • L7.7 Draw suggestions out of other members of a discussion, and take notes on what they said.
  • L7.8 Identify where a discussion has reached agreement and where it has not, without blurring the difference.

Epistemic Anchor

Every other lodestar in this set depends on words. A student with a thin vocabulary will read shallowly, however well he has been taught to read. Greek and Latin roots give the greatest return on study. A sixth grader who knows scrib and jus can reach hundreds of words he has not yet met. So the study of roots supports every other lodestar in the set.

This lodestar scores discussion as a set of capacities, not as participation. A student who can hear a position well enough to state it back has gained in speech what Lodestar 2 forms in writing. A student who will say plainly that a group has not agreed has gained something rarer and more useful. A discussion that ends in false agreement teaches the opposite. The rubric scores both capacities.

At this grade, presentation asks for a stance, not only for information. A student who holds a position in front of others learns that he is answerable for what he says. Written work alone does not form this.

Assessment Signature

Summative. A prepared presentation on a stance the student has taken, followed by a student-led discussion. In the discussion he states another participant's position accurately before answering it. He closes by identifying where the group agreed and where it did not. Scored by this lodestar's rubric.

Formative. Root and affix work applied to unfamiliar academic words; exercises in inferring meaning from context; short listening checks that require a message to be restated before it is answered; and brief discussion routines that require notes and a closing statement of any disagreement left unresolved.

Rubric

DimensionExemplaryEstablishedDevelopingBeginning
Word knowledgeUses roots and context to establish the meaning of an unfamiliar academic word, and confirms it against a resource.Determines meaning from roots, context, or resources accurately.Determines meaning inconsistently, or relies on one method only.Guesses at meaning without method, or does not attempt it.
Listening and restatementRestates another's position accurately enough that the speaker accepts the restatement, then answers it.Restates what was said without distortion.Restates the gist but loses what the speaker actually claimed.Answers a position that was not advanced.
PresentationTakes a clear stance, organizes the whole presentation to support it, and controls eye contact, rate, volume, and enunciation throughout.Presents an organized position with adequate control of delivery.Presents information without a stance, or holds a stance without organization.Neither organized nor audible enough to follow.
Discussion conductDraws out members who have not spoken, records what they said, and names any remaining disagreement plainly.Contributes, takes notes, and identifies agreement and disagreement.Contributes without attending to others, or attends without contributing.Does not participate, or participates in a way that prevents others from doing so.
Reference
TEKS Correspondence
LodestarTEKS strandWhat this lodestar carries
Lodestar 1(b)(3)Adjustment of reading fluency to the purpose for reading.
Lodestar 1(b)(4)Self-selected, sustained independent reading.
Lodestar 1(b)(5)(A)-(I)Purpose for reading, question generation, prediction and its correction, mental imagery, connection to experience and to other texts, inference supported by evidence, evaluation of details for key ideas, synthesis across material, and comprehension monitoring and repair.
Lodestar 1(b)(6)(A)-(I)Personal connection to sources, written response demonstrating understanding and comparing sources within and across genres, use of text evidence, paraphrase and summary preserving meaning and order, interaction with sources through notetaking and annotation, use of newly acquired vocabulary, explicit and implicit meaning, control of register, tone, and voice, and revision of a response as new evidence appears.
Lodestar 1(b)(9)(A)-(B)The author's purpose and message within a text, and how text structure contributes to that purpose.
Lodestar 2(b)(8)(E)The characteristics and structures of argumentative text: identifying the claim, explaining the author's use of various types of evidence, and identifying the intended audience or reader.
Lodestar 2(b)(9)(G)The differences between rhetorical devices and logical fallacies.
Lodestar 2(b)(12)(A)-(J)Question generation for formal and informal inquiry, developing and revising a plan, refinement of the major research question, gathering relevant information from a variety of sources, primary and secondary sources, synthesis across sources, paraphrase distinguished from plagiarism, examination of sources for reliability, credibility, bias, and faulty reasoning, academic citation and ethical use of source materials, and an appropriate mode of delivery for results.
Lodestar 3(b)(7)(A)-(D)Inference of multiple themes within and across texts using text evidence, the development of plot through characters' internal and external responses, plot elements including rising action, climax, falling action, resolution, and non-linear elements, and the influence of setting including historical and cultural settings on character and plot.
Lodestar 3(b)(8)(C)How playwrights develop characters through dialogue and staging.
Lodestar 4(b)(8)(B)The effect of meter and of structural elements such as line breaks in poems across a variety of poetic forms.
Lodestar 4(b)(9)(C)-(F)The author's use of print and graphic features to achieve specific purposes, figurative language such as metaphor and personification achieving specific purposes, literary devices including omniscient and limited point of view, and the contribution of an author's use of language to mood and voice.
Lodestar 5(b)(8)(A)Knowledge of literary genres and their characteristics.
Lodestar 5(b)(8)(D)Characteristics and structural elements of informational text: the controlling idea or thesis with supporting evidence, features supplying background, and organizational patterns including definition, classification, and advantage and disadvantage.
Lodestar 5(b)(8)(F)Characteristics of multimodal and digital texts.
Lodestar 6(b)(10)(A)-(C), (E)Planning a first draft by genre, topic, purpose, and audience; developing drafts into focused, structured, coherent writing with purposeful organization and developed ideas; revising for clarity, development, organization, style, word choice, and sentence variety; and publishing written work for an appropriate audience.
Lodestar 6(b)(10)(D)(i)-(ix)The conventions of standard English named for this grade, in full: complete complex sentences with subject-verb agreement and without splices, run-ons, or fragments; consistent verb tense; conjunctive adverbs; prepositions and prepositional phrases and their influence on agreement; pronouns including relative pronouns; subordinating and correlative conjunctions; capitalization of proper nouns including abbreviations, initials, acronyms, and organizations; punctuation including commas in complex sentences, with transitions, and with introductory elements; and correct spelling including commonly confused terms.
Lodestar 6(b)(11)(A)-(D)Composition of literary texts, informational texts including multi-paragraph essays organized on a controlling idea or thesis, multi-paragraph argumentative texts, and correspondence in business or friendly structure.
Lodestar 7(b)(1)(A)-(D)Active listening to interpret a message, clarifying questions and appropriate response, following and giving multi-step oral instructions, organized presentation with a specific stance and position including the conventions of spoken delivery, and participation in student-led discussion including eliciting suggestions, taking notes, and identifying points of agreement and disagreement.
Lodestar 7(b)(2)(A)-(C)Print and digital resources for meaning, syllabication, pronunciation, word origin, and part of speech; context including definition, analogy, and example; and grade-level academic English words derived from Greek and Latin roots.
ESO Mapping
LodestarESOHow the standard exercises it
Lodestar 12.2Makes the weighing of evidence for a reading, not recall of content, the object of mastery.
Lodestar 12.6Builds independent reading by teaching a reader to notice and repair his own failures to understand.
Lodestar 12.9Claims sustained independent reading as growth in judgment about what deserves attention.
Lodestar 11.3.1Forms the habit of reading for an author's intention, on which sound biblical interpretation depends.
Lodestar 22.2Makes the careful weighing of a claim and its evidence the object of assessment.
Lodestar 22.6Equips independent inquiry by teaching a student to find, test, and credit what he finds.
Lodestar 21.5.2Treats careful reasoning about a disputed claim as a practical way of loving God with the mind.
Lodestar 24.3.1Requires a student to state another person's position in terms its holder would accept.
Lodestar 31.4.2Uses the reading of character as an occasion for what Scripture teaches about human nature.
Lodestar 35.2.3Has a student trace how an inward response issues in speech and action, first in a character and then in himself.
Lodestar 32.9Builds the capacity to read enduring literature closely enough to be formed by it.
Lodestar 32.2Requires that a claim about theme be supported from the structure of the work.
Lodestar 42.8Trains the attention an art requires by having a student explain how an effect was produced.
Lodestar 42.9Equips a student to read enduring literature at the level of its language, not only its plot.
Lodestar 41.3.1Builds the attention to genre and figure that historical-grammatical reading of Scripture requires.
Lodestar 42.2Requires that a claim about an effect be shown from the text's actual language.
Lodestar 52.3Has a student carry one question across texts of different kinds and explain what each form can and cannot do.
Lodestar 52.12Builds discernment about what a digital text is built to do, which supports safe and wise practice online.
Lodestar 52.2Makes the fit between form and purpose a matter of analysis, not preference.
Lodestar 62.10Makes written communication the direct object of assessment across four forms.
Lodestar 62.2Requires that an idea be developed with specific support, not asserted and padded.
Lodestar 64.3.4Trains the writing of correspondence that states a position, makes a complaint, or makes a request in terms a reader can receive.
Lodestar 72.2Makes accurate hearing and restatement of another's position a scored capacity.
Lodestar 74.3.1Requires that other members of a discussion be drawn out and represented accurately.
Lodestar 74.3.4Trains the communication of a position and its grounds to people who may not share it.